??????BOOK REVIEW
The Cost of Power in China, The Three Gorges Dam and the Yangtze River Valley
By Steven Benson

Photographs and Narratives by Steven Benson
Introduction and Afterword by Dai Qing
Essay by A.D. Coleman
Interview by Jens Friis
Published by Black Opal Press, P.O. Box 405, Lake Orion, Michigan 48361, USA
Copyright 2006
224 pages; 162 duotone photographs
The pages are not numbered so I am taking Steve at his word in emails back to me. The first in September 2006:
“Thank you for your interest in the book. Your patience is greatly appreciated during the production period.
“The book is at the printer and you’ll be happy to know that since the time of your purchase, the book has grown from 144 pages and 90 photos to 220 pages and 158 photos! This is all at no additional cost to you.”
And again in February:
“The book grew a little more, 224 pages and 162 duotones.”
In some cases, growth is most appreciated!
This book is a precursor to a fate for a large community in south central China. The fate is in actuality taking place at this time but will enlarge many fold as the years pass by. It is a precursor in the same sense that W. Eugene Smith’s Minamata is the aftermath documentation of a community within a fate that in all probability had been known but ignored or deliberately hidden.
As I sat with the book leafing through page after page I became aware of subtle feelings—I was being introduced to a part of China that was 180 degrees from what I’d seen on PBS television specials of young couples visiting China. What I was seeing now were vast amounts of uncontrolled air, land, and water pollution. It was not until the middle of the book that I was almost startled by seeing sharp, sun-cast shadows! The captions and running commentaries certainly supported that but only rarely were there signs of sun or clear skies. One of Steve’s comments at the end of the book added to my growing feelings and thought it might have helped me as a reader if it had been at the beginning of the book.
Steve, from the interview:
“. . . The other strategy at work here is what I call the ‘Beautiful Poisonous Snake Aesthetic.’ The images are gentle and respectful while the text is hard hitting and political. Actually, I would also add the way that I decided to print these photographs. The quality of the prints in terms of tonality function as a voice for the images and it is a soft voice. I spent a great deal of time on the prints, more than I have with other images from other projects and there seems to be a particular importance about ‘the voice’ of them.’?
I was seeing people living in a gray. There are three groups of people within these pages: the refugees to be; the workers constructing the project; and the invisible government people who pushed the project even after having been warned by world experts.
Steve:
“The disappearance of 36,000 square miles of our planet was not the result of an erupting Mt. Vesuvius—it was the result of the human decision making process at its most destructive. It is my hope that this body of work, in conjunction with the photographs and written records of my colleagues, might somehow function as a warning to future generations to never make this mistake again.”
This is a book that cries out to be seen and pointed to and learned from.
I first met Steve Benson at the Meeting Place during FotoFest 2006, Houston, Texas where he was showing to those waiting for portfolio reviews, both photographers and reviewers, his mock-up of his dynamic and thought provoking book. His work on this enormous project in China is reportage and documentary, a genré that to my eyes appeared lacking in the majority of photographs being brought to FotoFest. Few Magnum type photographers were present as the majority of reviewers represented museums and galleries, places where emphasis moves along the lines of fine art, design, and manipulations via processes. The reviewers had been reviewed by the attending photographers, which in and of itself determines strongly what images will be brought to FotoFest. Therein lies the irony of FotoFest. Some of this book’s very same images were in a featured exhibition at FotoFest 2004. Steve traveled the entire length of the proposed reservoir in 1999 thus a five year time frame from shoot to show.
For those of you who work in the documentary arena and have questions about getting into FotoFest, you might just contact Steve, purchase his book and maybe get some answers.
After I went through the images Steve asked if I had time to look at other photos he’d been working on over quite a long period. They were paradoxes—discoveries of everyday things we all see but then move on. Steve stops, ponders, and shoots. One of them is at the very end of his book, six pages from the end. It supports his last answer during the interview by Jens Friis. I can only report on parts of the two images, back to back—”NEW! HOT AND FRESH BAGELS” and “PRAY 4 OUR AMERICA”.
Serious photographers?
November 7th, 2009Where have we been, as photographers?
Needle in light bulb with reflector
This evening, Friday, November 6, 2009, as I sit at my small table, Max, my German Shepherd sleeps lightly on the couch a couple feet away. I’ve been going over the night photographs I’ve made during the past year-and-a-half. This past Sunday I conducted another night time workshop in a country setting with the full moon illuminating the different scenes. On November 15, another Sunday, the group will be downtown Houston to shoot various scenes without a moon. (more)
Tags: Beaumont Newhall, Gina Weston, Kim Weston, Photographers Links, Riane Eisler
Posted in General News/Commentary | No Comments »